Laptop screen showing large diverse video conference call representing MediaReach's remote collaboration culture

Mar 5, 2021

Does Team Diversity Add Value for Brands and Agencies?

As the UK grows more diverse, are ad agencies keeping up? The data on representation, financial returns, creativity and why token hires backfire.

⏱ 4 min read

By mediareach

As the UK becomes increasingly diverse, marketing teams and ad agencies are asking whether that diversity is accurately represented inside their own industry.


Why does it matter? And will simply adding more diversity improve performance, or does it need more thought?

How Diverse Are Brand and Ad Agency Teams?

According to the 2020 IPA Agency Census, 15.8% of staff at media agencies and 12.3% at Creative/Other agencies are from a BAME background. That's roughly in line with the UK population figure of 13.8% BAME.


But it is well below the IPA's own 2015 targets- 25% of new starters from a BAME background by 2020, and the gap widens at senior levels. BAME representation at C-suite is just 4.7%, far short of the 15% target.


The pattern is even more pronounced beyond advertising. Recent data shows 37% of FTSE 100 companies did not have a single BAME director on their board, raising questions about representation in boardrooms versus the communities brands serve.

Diverse team collaborating around computer screen representing MediaReach's integrated agency teamwork and data analysis

What Are The Benefits of Greater Diversity?

Diversity correlates with performance. McKinsey analysed data from Canada, Latin America, the UK and US and found companies in the top quartile for racial and ethnic diversity were 35% more likely to see financial returns exceeding their country's average. For gender diversity, the figure was 15% more likely.

Other benefits go beyond finance. A Harvard Business Review study found diverse teams solve problems faster by bringing a wider range of perspectives to the table.

Retention and talent attraction also improve. A Deloitte survey revealed 39% of workers would leave their organisation to join a more inclusive one, and 23% already had. Glassdoor found 3 out of 4 job seekers in the US say a diverse workforce is an important factor when considering an offer.


DIVERSITY DATA

Why Diversity Drives Creativity


  1. McKinsey: Top quartile ethnic diversity = 35% more likely to outperform financially; gender diversity = 15% more likely.

  2. HBR: Diverse teams solve problems faster.

  3. Deloitte: 39% would leave for more inclusive org, 23% already did.

  4. Glassdoor: 75% of job seekers say diversity matters in job offers.

  5. Creative view: “Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have ability to be tone deaf.” – Lincoln Stephens, CEO Marcus Graham Project


Creative output is a key gain. Lincoln Stephens, CEO of US non-profit The Marcus Graham Project which creates opportunities in advertising for diverse backgrounds, pointed out that authentic campaigns need perspective: “Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have the ability to be tone deaf.”

Alex Goat, Chief Executive of youth-led creative network Livity in London, echoed it: “Creativity and diversity are inextricably linked” and proven time and again that more diverse teams lead to more creative solutions and innovation.

Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have the ability to be tone deaf.

Lincoln Stephens

CEO, The Marcus Graham Project

Not Enough On Its Own: The Token Hire Risk

While greater diversity is positive, how diverse teams function in practice matters. If companies hire more inclusively with little thought to managing a culturally diverse team, they risk being accused of token hires.



Brands and agencies should treat diversity as part of a broader strategy, not a tick-box exercise.


Christina Brooks, CEO of diversity-focused software company Ruebik, warned: “Token hiring is just window dressing with no real commitment to infrastructural change or challenging problematic behaviours around inclusion and culture.”


Arthur Woods, Co-Founder of diversity recruiting platform Mathison, added that organisations that focus only on hiring often fail to retain and advance those job seekers: “Amongst underrepresented populations individuals step into an organisation, they don’t receive mentorship and support from other leaders, they don’t see leaders [like them] at the top. So they wonder, is there a place for me here?”

Brands and agencies still have more to do to build an inclusive and representative workforce. Greater diversity can drive financial returns, faster problem-solving, talent attraction and more authentic creativity, but only when long-term inclusion strategies are in place.

Worried woman facing holographic Predictor AI screens showing personal data 99.8% accuracy psyche profile, website tracking

Build Diversity That Adds Real Value

Mediareach helps brands move beyond token hires to inclusive teams that deliver better financial, creative and cultural results.

Sources & References
  1. IPA Agency Census 2020 via Campaign Live – 15.8% media agencies, 12.3% Creative/Other BAME, 4.7% C-suite vs 25% new starters and 15% C-suite targets.

  2. Diversity UK – 13.8% BAME population in UK.

  3. EY via Guardian – 37% FTSE 100 companies had no BAME director.

  4. McKinsey – top quartile ethnic diversity 35% more likely to exceed average returns, gender diversity 15%.

  5. Harvard Business Review – cognitively diverse teams solve problems faster.

  6. Deloitte – 39% would leave for more inclusive org, 23% already had; Glassdoor – 3/4 job seekers say diverse workforce important.

  7. Think with Google – Lincoln Stephens Marcus Graham Project and Alex Goat Livity on perspective and creativity.

  8. Vanderbilt, Wired, Marketplace – token hiring risks, Ruebik CEO Christina Brooks and Mathison Co-Founder Arthur Woods on retention and mentorship.

diversity brand agency teams value

BAME representation advertising

IPA Agency Census 2020

McKinsey diversity financial performance

inclusive teams creativity

token hiring diversity

FTSE 100 BAME directors

Harvard Business Review diverse teams

Deloitte inclusion retention

Glassdoor diversity job seekers

The UK's pioneering multicultural marketing and advertising agency. Over 40 years connecting brands with diverse communities through cultural insight, creative excellence, and intelligent media strategy.

SEO Head
Laptop screen showing large diverse video conference call representing MediaReach's remote collaboration culture

Mar 5, 2021

Does Team Diversity Add Value for Brands and Agencies?

As the UK grows more diverse, are ad agencies keeping up? The data on representation, financial returns, creativity and why token hires backfire.

⏱ 4 min read

By mediareach

As the UK becomes increasingly diverse, marketing teams and ad agencies are asking whether that diversity is accurately represented inside their own industry.


Why does it matter? And will simply adding more diversity improve performance, or does it need more thought?

How Diverse Are Brand and Ad Agency Teams?

According to the 2020 IPA Agency Census, 15.8% of staff at media agencies and 12.3% at Creative/Other agencies are from a BAME background. That's roughly in line with the UK population figure of 13.8% BAME.


But it is well below the IPA's own 2015 targets- 25% of new starters from a BAME background by 2020, and the gap widens at senior levels. BAME representation at C-suite is just 4.7%, far short of the 15% target.


The pattern is even more pronounced beyond advertising. Recent data shows 37% of FTSE 100 companies did not have a single BAME director on their board, raising questions about representation in boardrooms versus the communities brands serve.

Diverse team collaborating around computer screen representing MediaReach's integrated agency teamwork and data analysis

What Are The Benefits of Greater Diversity?

Diversity correlates with performance. McKinsey analysed data from Canada, Latin America, the UK and US and found companies in the top quartile for racial and ethnic diversity were 35% more likely to see financial returns exceeding their country's average. For gender diversity, the figure was 15% more likely.

Other benefits go beyond finance. A Harvard Business Review study found diverse teams solve problems faster by bringing a wider range of perspectives to the table.

Retention and talent attraction also improve. A Deloitte survey revealed 39% of workers would leave their organisation to join a more inclusive one, and 23% already had. Glassdoor found 3 out of 4 job seekers in the US say a diverse workforce is an important factor when considering an offer.


DIVERSITY DATA

Why Diversity Drives Creativity


  1. McKinsey: Top quartile ethnic diversity = 35% more likely to outperform financially; gender diversity = 15% more likely.

  2. HBR: Diverse teams solve problems faster.

  3. Deloitte: 39% would leave for more inclusive org, 23% already did.

  4. Glassdoor: 75% of job seekers say diversity matters in job offers.

  5. Creative view: “Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have ability to be tone deaf.” – Lincoln Stephens, CEO Marcus Graham Project


Creative output is a key gain. Lincoln Stephens, CEO of US non-profit The Marcus Graham Project which creates opportunities in advertising for diverse backgrounds, pointed out that authentic campaigns need perspective: “Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have the ability to be tone deaf.”

Alex Goat, Chief Executive of youth-led creative network Livity in London, echoed it: “Creativity and diversity are inextricably linked” and proven time and again that more diverse teams lead to more creative solutions and innovation.

Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have the ability to be tone deaf.

Lincoln Stephens

CEO, The Marcus Graham Project

Not Enough On Its Own: The Token Hire Risk

While greater diversity is positive, how diverse teams function in practice matters. If companies hire more inclusively with little thought to managing a culturally diverse team, they risk being accused of token hires.



Brands and agencies should treat diversity as part of a broader strategy, not a tick-box exercise.


Christina Brooks, CEO of diversity-focused software company Ruebik, warned: “Token hiring is just window dressing with no real commitment to infrastructural change or challenging problematic behaviours around inclusion and culture.”


Arthur Woods, Co-Founder of diversity recruiting platform Mathison, added that organisations that focus only on hiring often fail to retain and advance those job seekers: “Amongst underrepresented populations individuals step into an organisation, they don’t receive mentorship and support from other leaders, they don’t see leaders [like them] at the top. So they wonder, is there a place for me here?”

Brands and agencies still have more to do to build an inclusive and representative workforce. Greater diversity can drive financial returns, faster problem-solving, talent attraction and more authentic creativity, but only when long-term inclusion strategies are in place.

Worried woman facing holographic Predictor AI screens showing personal data 99.8% accuracy psyche profile, website tracking

Build Diversity That Adds Real Value

Mediareach helps brands move beyond token hires to inclusive teams that deliver better financial, creative and cultural results.

Sources & References
  1. IPA Agency Census 2020 via Campaign Live – 15.8% media agencies, 12.3% Creative/Other BAME, 4.7% C-suite vs 25% new starters and 15% C-suite targets.

  2. Diversity UK – 13.8% BAME population in UK.

  3. EY via Guardian – 37% FTSE 100 companies had no BAME director.

  4. McKinsey – top quartile ethnic diversity 35% more likely to exceed average returns, gender diversity 15%.

  5. Harvard Business Review – cognitively diverse teams solve problems faster.

  6. Deloitte – 39% would leave for more inclusive org, 23% already had; Glassdoor – 3/4 job seekers say diverse workforce important.

  7. Think with Google – Lincoln Stephens Marcus Graham Project and Alex Goat Livity on perspective and creativity.

  8. Vanderbilt, Wired, Marketplace – token hiring risks, Ruebik CEO Christina Brooks and Mathison Co-Founder Arthur Woods on retention and mentorship.

diversity brand agency teams value

BAME representation advertising

IPA Agency Census 2020

McKinsey diversity financial performance

inclusive teams creativity

token hiring diversity

FTSE 100 BAME directors

Harvard Business Review diverse teams

Deloitte inclusion retention

Glassdoor diversity job seekers

The UK's pioneering multicultural marketing and advertising agency. Over 40 years connecting brands with diverse communities through cultural insight, creative excellence, and intelligent media strategy.

SEO Head
Laptop screen showing large diverse video conference call representing MediaReach's remote collaboration culture

Mar 5, 2021

Does Team Diversity Add Value for Brands and Agencies?

As the UK grows more diverse, are ad agencies keeping up? The data on representation, financial returns, creativity and why token hires backfire.

⏱ 4 min read

By mediareach

As the UK becomes increasingly diverse, marketing teams and ad agencies are asking whether that diversity is accurately represented inside their own industry.


Why does it matter? And will simply adding more diversity improve performance, or does it need more thought?

How Diverse Are Brand and Ad Agency Teams?

According to the 2020 IPA Agency Census, 15.8% of staff at media agencies and 12.3% at Creative/Other agencies are from a BAME background. That's roughly in line with the UK population figure of 13.8% BAME.


But it is well below the IPA's own 2015 targets- 25% of new starters from a BAME background by 2020, and the gap widens at senior levels. BAME representation at C-suite is just 4.7%, far short of the 15% target.


The pattern is even more pronounced beyond advertising. Recent data shows 37% of FTSE 100 companies did not have a single BAME director on their board, raising questions about representation in boardrooms versus the communities brands serve.

Diverse team collaborating around computer screen representing MediaReach's integrated agency teamwork and data analysis

What Are The Benefits of Greater Diversity?

Diversity correlates with performance. McKinsey analysed data from Canada, Latin America, the UK and US and found companies in the top quartile for racial and ethnic diversity were 35% more likely to see financial returns exceeding their country's average. For gender diversity, the figure was 15% more likely.

Other benefits go beyond finance. A Harvard Business Review study found diverse teams solve problems faster by bringing a wider range of perspectives to the table.

Retention and talent attraction also improve. A Deloitte survey revealed 39% of workers would leave their organisation to join a more inclusive one, and 23% already had. Glassdoor found 3 out of 4 job seekers in the US say a diverse workforce is an important factor when considering an offer.


DIVERSITY DATA

Why Diversity Drives Creativity


  1. McKinsey: Top quartile ethnic diversity = 35% more likely to outperform financially; gender diversity = 15% more likely.

  2. HBR: Diverse teams solve problems faster.

  3. Deloitte: 39% would leave for more inclusive org, 23% already did.

  4. Glassdoor: 75% of job seekers say diversity matters in job offers.

  5. Creative view: “Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have ability to be tone deaf.” – Lincoln Stephens, CEO Marcus Graham Project


Creative output is a key gain. Lincoln Stephens, CEO of US non-profit The Marcus Graham Project which creates opportunities in advertising for diverse backgrounds, pointed out that authentic campaigns need perspective: “Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have the ability to be tone deaf.”

Alex Goat, Chief Executive of youth-led creative network Livity in London, echoed it: “Creativity and diversity are inextricably linked” and proven time and again that more diverse teams lead to more creative solutions and innovation.

Perspective breeds thoughtful creativity. When they lack perspective, brands have the ability to be tone deaf.

Lincoln Stephens

CEO, The Marcus Graham Project

Not Enough On Its Own: The Token Hire Risk

While greater diversity is positive, how diverse teams function in practice matters. If companies hire more inclusively with little thought to managing a culturally diverse team, they risk being accused of token hires.



Brands and agencies should treat diversity as part of a broader strategy, not a tick-box exercise.


Christina Brooks, CEO of diversity-focused software company Ruebik, warned: “Token hiring is just window dressing with no real commitment to infrastructural change or challenging problematic behaviours around inclusion and culture.”


Arthur Woods, Co-Founder of diversity recruiting platform Mathison, added that organisations that focus only on hiring often fail to retain and advance those job seekers: “Amongst underrepresented populations individuals step into an organisation, they don’t receive mentorship and support from other leaders, they don’t see leaders [like them] at the top. So they wonder, is there a place for me here?”

Brands and agencies still have more to do to build an inclusive and representative workforce. Greater diversity can drive financial returns, faster problem-solving, talent attraction and more authentic creativity, but only when long-term inclusion strategies are in place.

Worried woman facing holographic Predictor AI screens showing personal data 99.8% accuracy psyche profile, website tracking

Build Diversity That Adds Real Value

Mediareach helps brands move beyond token hires to inclusive teams that deliver better financial, creative and cultural results.

Sources & References
  1. IPA Agency Census 2020 via Campaign Live – 15.8% media agencies, 12.3% Creative/Other BAME, 4.7% C-suite vs 25% new starters and 15% C-suite targets.

  2. Diversity UK – 13.8% BAME population in UK.

  3. EY via Guardian – 37% FTSE 100 companies had no BAME director.

  4. McKinsey – top quartile ethnic diversity 35% more likely to exceed average returns, gender diversity 15%.

  5. Harvard Business Review – cognitively diverse teams solve problems faster.

  6. Deloitte – 39% would leave for more inclusive org, 23% already had; Glassdoor – 3/4 job seekers say diverse workforce important.

  7. Think with Google – Lincoln Stephens Marcus Graham Project and Alex Goat Livity on perspective and creativity.

  8. Vanderbilt, Wired, Marketplace – token hiring risks, Ruebik CEO Christina Brooks and Mathison Co-Founder Arthur Woods on retention and mentorship.

diversity brand agency teams value

BAME representation advertising

IPA Agency Census 2020

McKinsey diversity financial performance

inclusive teams creativity

token hiring diversity

FTSE 100 BAME directors

Harvard Business Review diverse teams

Deloitte inclusion retention

Glassdoor diversity job seekers

The UK's pioneering multicultural marketing and advertising agency. Over 40 years connecting brands with diverse communities through cultural insight, creative excellence, and intelligent media strategy.

SEO Head